essay 2011
The City Is Becoming
An essay on the city as a medium, written with Ben Cerveny and James Burke for Atlantis, the urbanism magazine of Polis at TU Delft, in its series on explorative urbanism.
The Medium is the Metropolis
The age of ubiquitous computation is condensing around us even as you read this. The various systems throughout a modern city that you probably interact with everyday are beginning to maintain persistent memories of their own use, communicate with each other about their status, and even reconfigure themselves based on your dynamic needs.
In the same way that social networks and digital representation have had profound consequences on the cultures of print, music, and video, so too will the urban fabric of the city itself be transformed into an information layered, collaboratively shapable medium.
Civic Information Systems
The modern city is built not just upon physical infrastructure, but also patterns and flows of information that are always growing and transforming. We are only now beginning to develop the tools that allow us to see these patterns of information over huge spans of time and space, or in any local context in realtime.
Just as the industrial age transformed cities with the addition of towers to the skyline and far-reaching transit networks, the digital age will bring new urban-scale infrastructure into everyday experience. Where the products of industrial urban evolution were huge physical manifestations that celebrated the magnitude of urban culture, the digital era is instead producing equally impressive manifestations that live “in the cloud”.
Collaborative redevelopment
The city is forever changing. While it is essential to preserve and nurture many environments and characteristics that give a city its texture and unique life, the needs of citizens often evolve beyond the purposes or constraints upon which buildings or infrastructure were initially constructed. The problem of designing urban redevelopment to meet new needs without disrupting the texture and life of the city has frustrated many a planning department.
Digital culture has been evolving strategies to approach its own development challenges. The production of complex programs like operating systems require the orchestration of countless intricate tasks across hundreds of participants, while the building of massive online references like Wikipedia combine the efforts of thousands. We can build tools that provide the same massively collaborative framework around the transformation of the city itself.
Urban Systems Literacy
As a culture, we are evolving more and more ways to perceive patterns in complexity. Most of our scientific pursuits in the last half a century have been in mapping the behavior of complex systems. We have even developed an entire field of entertainment, game design, to tap the enjoyment we instinctively feel in understanding ‘rule spaces’. These new literacies can now be focused on the web of relationships that make up a city. Modeling techniques popularized by science, and made both popular and culturally meaningful by game design, can now be used by people on the streets to get a better understanding of what is shaping the world right around them.
Responsive Environments
Within a dynamic urban infrastructure, city-scale services like power, data, and transportation begin to adapt in realtime to the changing needs of the public. Potentially, other digital services like projection and audio systems, or even the transformation of physical space, could be layered into the public sphere. What are the mechanisms by which these services are provisioned by the tasks that citizens utilize them for?
Urban Interface Policy
As the city becomes the site of dynamic systems that can provide services and transform environments in public space, it is imperative that we consider carefully the ethics and politics of these infrastructures. In the smart city, what is written as programmatic software ‘code’ can easily become de facto ‘law’ as it imposes permissioning schemes and identity regimes on its participants. So far, the internet, and the open source software that powers much of it, has remained remarkably adaptable to the ideals of democratic and egalitarian societies. Every infrastructural advance, however, goes through a watershed moment where the governing design principles of the technology itself begin to influence the types of societal experiences they might produce. We need to attempt to understand the cultural ramifications of such infrastructural design decisions in this context.
VURB
VURB is a European framework for policy and design research concerning urban computational systems. The VURB foundation, based in Amsterdam, provides direction and resources to a portfolio of projects investigating how our cultures might come to use networked digital resources to change the way we understand, build, and inhabit cities. Of these projects, two are highlighted here: Vacant Amsterdam, a study for exposing empty state-owned spaces via networking technologies to local communities; and Urbanode, a prototype for discoverable services in public space.
Vacant Amsterdam: Platform for cities
VURB Foundation together with partners will explore the reuse potential of vacant urban space through tools like social networks. This scan of the near future will give urban planners and civil servants as well as state-owned property managers insight and the possibility to see real demand for space reuse and experiment with how resource allocation would change under the impact of networked technologies.
Space and the City
Surprisingly, two projects, in Spain and the Netherlands, highlight the frequency of empty office and state-owned property reminding us of the huge waste of space in our cities; dusty, static spaces hidden away behind thick doors under lock and key from city neighbors who would wish to reuse them.
At the same time there exists a rich tradition of hybrid spaces and within many cities a continual ebb and flow of old being appropriated for reuse. The arrival of networked technologies has resulted in new sites and services continuing these rich tradtions while updating how we go about reclaiming empty spaces, from the enervating rise of pop-ups to small communities and issue networks.
Exposing empty state-owned spaces via networking technologies to local communities
VURB Foundation is investigating how networked technologies working as a civic service may gather and make visible unused buildings and their progeny, rooms and corridors, as a low level digital architecture which can be used by others to negotiate reuse and increase the “refresh rate” at which cities reallocate space. The project will aim to help identify citizens urban spatial hunger while working with partner organizations like local government and housing organizations to make the connection between law, space and its responsible management and availability.
This project is then meant to augment existing practises and communities, of which there are many, as an exploration into how these might co-exist. We ask whether the fallow ground of vacant city space can be repopulated and made to a far great extent accessible to citizens? Can we reappropriate more urban fallow space to its inhabitants at a reasonable price and even maintained by volunteers?
A network of vacant spaces
VURB Foundation intends to build a social software platform prototype listing the empty buildings (or the parts of them that are) in the city. Citizens will then be able to join this network and express demand for reusing such spaces using voting, discussion and simple conversational and design tools. This will be developed in partnership with local government and organizations already running hybrid spaces.
Urbanode
Citizens will begin to gain the ability to affect their environment in new ways, using city services the way they would use a digital application in an online environment. Transportation systems, lighting systems, public media hardware like active signage and sound-systems will become objects available for activation, control, and coordination by tools and services that citizens use in their everyday lives. Through collaborative interaction with such tools, users of public spaces can configure them for specific temporary functions and even begin to ‘perform’ space together.
Prototypes for discoverable services in public space
One of our main research objectives at VURB is to explore the possible dynamics between a digitally empowered citizenry and their increasingly ‘smart’, reactive public environment. What types of network services in public space will become institutionalized public infrastructure, taken for granted like transit systems? How will public and private domains of network services interact? Who will be allowed to make changes to environmental systems in public contexts? And whose role is it to make any of these decisions?
In order to investigate these questions, VURB has embarked on a series of software development projects to enable real-world prototyping of scriptable public space, where environmental controls like lighting, audio, and projection can be controlled via a local javascript server. This local server can then present scripted applications, built around specific tasks and user scenarios, as dynamically discoverable services to citizens in the space, whether via a mobile browser or through gesture and voice commands. Ultimately, the aim of these projects is to understand the implications of ‘digital experience architecture’ as an aspect of urban design, where public space becomes dynamically adaptive to the needs of its occupants and the city weaves together a mesh of these dynamic locations into a platform for citizen-enabling network applications.
VURB has just completed an initial development effort toward enabling such programmable spaces. The Urbanode project, a research partnership with Digitale Pioniers, begins the process of creating public system software by wrapping the controls for lighting control systems, such as those found in theaters and nightclubs, in a javascript programming framework. Recently, a prototype of this system has successfully been deployed for testing and development in the Melkweg, one of the premiere venues for live music in Amsterdam.
Spatial Object Model
Javascript is well on its way to being the default choice of lightweight scripting notations for all types of webservices. It has become common practice for any large-scale social networks, streaming media services, and informations systems to present a publicly accessible javascript application programming interface, or API, so that third party developers can call on their functions or read their data in any program. In HTML5, the latest specification for web browser functionality, javascript takes on animation capabilities with the concept of a canvas that the application can draw to, as well as the more traditional mechanisms for creating dynamic applications by manipulating the Document Object Model. In Urbanode, we start to apply these same document-related scripting paradigms to space itself. How do you write applications in javascript that treat space as a canvas? What does the Spatial Object Model, or SOM, look like?
User scenarios
In thinking about designing for programmable spaces, it might be useful to consider a few user scenarios. In this first pass at understanding the design opportunities, lets look at use cases in 3 separate categories of interaction: direct manipulation, environmental control and ambient information.
Direct manipulation
Direct manipulation is perhaps the most straightforward example. A user might come into a danceclub or other venue and open their Urbanode browser on their mobile device. The Urbanode browser would query the local server and return a list of applications available in the space. In this scenario, let’s suppose there is only one called “Light Commander”. The user selects this application and the browser retrieves the appropriate web interface, which initially presents a schematic view of the lighting in the space, with each light color-coded to indicate whether it is under the control of the venue operator, another user, or available to be controlled. The user taps on an ‘open’ spotlight and is presented with a control interface with a color wheel, directional controls, sliders for focus and brightness, and light pattern icons. There might also be a timer counting down a short interval until the light reverts to ‘open’ and must be re-acquired.
Environmental control
Environmental control is oriented around locations within the space, rather than specific pieces of controllable hardware. In the scenario we will consider here, let’s imagine a restaurant in which each table has network-accessible properties like “mood” or “energy level”. When the diners first sit, they can open the Urbanode browser and scan a symbol on the table with their phone’s camera to log-in to that space. The application presented is a simple scrolling list of mood choices like “romantic”, “party”, and “family”. Each choice dynamically effects the table-specific lighting brightness, color, and variation over time. These mood choices might also reconfigure the music stream or other audio, and also be displayed to the staff on a separate monitor so they might choose to service tables differently depending on selected mood.
Ambient information
Ambient information applications serve as ways to map data from network sources [webservices data, mobile device polling, or sensor data] to attributes of environmental mediation like lighting or audio. Let’s suppose the spotlighting on an obelisk in a public square is programmable using Urbanode. A citizen with permission to control those lights could build an application that displayed realtime sporting information using abstract color patterns and sequences. As citizens entered the square, they could consult their mobile devices, open the Urbanode browser, choose the “SportsMonument” application, and learn what the color mappings represented [say a soccer match in which the team colors of the team in the lead would be displayed, brighter depending on how big the lead is].
These examples are by no means an exhaustive catalogue of possible uses of the Urbanode infrastructure. On the contrary, we hope this initial framework inspires a whole range of uses, many surprising to us. We plan to continue adding to the catalog of environmental services Urbanode can control, starting a broader range of lighting equipment and eventually audio hardware and projectors. This kickoff phase in collaboration with Digitale Pioniers marks a strong start to an ongoing investigation of how we will build and live in the public spaces of the future. Or, as our dear friend and inspirator Bruce Sterling responded to the endless opportunites for Urbanode:
“Man, that’s for sure. Welcome to the 20-teens, here at last.”