essay 2015
The art of surveillance
The world after 9/11 has created its own art: the art of mass surveillance. Artists such as Martha Rosler, Laura Poitras and Trevor Paglen have joined the ranks of activists, whistleblowers and journalists in criticising the overreach of governments, intelligence agencies and corporations, who use the threat of terrorism to gain power, control and profit. By eavesdropping on the entire internet, outfitting cities with a network of cameras that record every step we take, and terrorising villages from the air with military drones. This is the dread of state terror.
Artists are addressing this injustice and violation of civil liberties, asking hard questions and imagining better answers in ways that are both novel and familiar. By creating counter-memes, designing anti-drone fashion, and photographing the invisible architectures of surveillance, artists are using the rules of engagement of the systems they critique.
Images especially, either photographed, filmed or designed, are a popular weapon of choice. Images are the currency of social media, earning their makers attention in the form of likes, shares and retweets. The most popular social media are image driven, such as Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, Qzone, Tumblr, Pinterest and Snapchat. And so are the most advanced systems of mass surveillance: drones, face recognition software and urban scale CCTV.
‘How Not To Be Seen: A Fucking Didactic Educational .MOV File’ by German artist Hito Steyerl is perhaps the stand-out work of art of mass surveillance. The work is an incredibly funny, absurdist and poignant ‘instruction video’ for making oneself invisible for surveillance cameras. The protagonist of the video is the artist herself, instructing the viewer in various lessons how not to be seen, such as “how to make something invisible for a camera“, “how to be invisible in plain sight” and “how to become invisible by becoming a picture.”
Visually the video takes its cues from the technology that it criticises, with Google Earth animations (satellites), stealthy green-screen projection (cameras), and military resolution targets (resolution) used as boomerang to strike back at the enemy. Sonically, it uses Apple’s native text-to-speech software for the narrators, giving the inanimate network a female and male a skeuomorphic design. The video works so well because of the dead-pan sense of humour of Hito Steyerl, the unmistakable ’truthiness’ of the subject, and because Steyerl just simply ‘gets’ contemporary aesthetics. This is a masterpiece of lulz, watching the watchers and receiving reddit gold over and over again.
Humour can be the most fearless messenger in tragedy. The book “Can Jokes Bring Down Governments?” by Dutch artists Metahaven is a study of humour, and especially internet humour that uses memes and trolling like you can find on 4Chan and Reddit. Metahaven can be credited with one of the best final sentences of any book: “Jokes are a continuation of politics by other memes.” (Joke explanation alert: this is a play on Clausewitz’s famous “War is a continuation of politics by other means”). Inspired by this book, and the research on the use of memes and hashtags by states and non-state actors, Metahaven are now working on ‘The Sprawl’, a cinematic adventure that will be published online later in 2015. It is a co-commission between Lighthouse and The Space, the online gallery for contemporary digital art supported by the BBC and the Arts Council of England. The focus of The Sprawl is “the way,” says Metahaven, “internet-based strategy by states, insurgent groups, and terrorist actors nowadays supplements ‘real’ and ‘physical’ conflicts and interacts with them.” Just think of the ‘hashtag surfing’ of ISIS during the 2014 FIFA World Cup, when the rogue state inserted propaganda videos of beheadings into trending topics on Twitter simply by adding popular hashtags. But also the way journalists like Bellingcat have used photographs and videos found on social media of military personnel and rebels to forensically investigate who shot down flight MH17 in Ukraine last year.
With the Sprawl Metahaven are creating a series of short online documentaries that, according to the artists, try “to understand and dissect the cultural, political, social and aesthetic relevance of internet-based conflict and its relationship to geopolitics and the social fabric.”
This is a mash-up of gonzo journalism, design vigilantism and radical digital art. A viral artistic campaign as a kind of counter-Kony2012.
Hito Steyerl and Metahaven are only two examples of numerous artists that deal with the contemporary by being truly contemporary. With their deep, heuristic and analytical understanding of the cultural ramifications of Moore’s Law, Silicon Valley and viral culture, they create necessary stories to counter the endless stream of commercial, mind-numbing and propagandist stories we encounter on our screens daily. They surf popular culture to make us look better at the media we consume. And they troll the powers of our nightmares, whether they are IS or the US.