article 2011
Controlling the City
An article on who controls the networked city, compiled with Michiel van Iersel in collaboration with Ben Cerveny for MONU #14, Editing Urbanism.
The contemporary city does not only consist of physical architecture, but is increasingly shaped by flows of data and information that are continuously transforming and expanding. The enormous increase in the use of hand- held devices and mobile applications in recent years is allowing a new and more direct interaction with our built environment. Together with the tools we use to design cities, the way we envision and understand cities is being transformed just as well. We are slowly beginning to develop systems that allow us to see urban development patterns over large spans of time and space, enabling us to use the information to really improve our cities.
Citizens now will gain the ability to affect their environment in new and direct ways, using and upgrading city services the way they would use a digital application online. Because of the far-reaching implications of the use of smartphones and through mobile social games and simulations, people can (re-)configure their environment for specific functions and interactive services. Your phone becomes a game controller. Lighting and transportation systems and public media hardware (i.e. active signage and sound-systems) will become objects available for activation, control, and coordination by tools and services that citizens are already using in their everyday lives. But what are the new technologies that enable us to (re-)shape our urban environment and how do the work? And who is controlling the coded city?
Playtime in cloud city
According to Ben Cerveny, a leading expert in the expanding domain of networked urbanism and co-founder of the VURB foundation, architects and urban planners have for years attempted to envision how dynamic structures and information systems would behave and operate. In the 60s artist Constant Nieuwenhuys imagined a New Babylon made of linked transformable structures that allowed its inhabitants to freely reconfigure their environment to fit their needs and desires in realtime. This Utopian fantasy was provocative at the time, but also hinted at a new relationship between citizens and their context. We are now entering an era where technology truly begins to weave together the desires of citizens and the services available to them in cities in realtime.
“But what does the use of these new systems look like?” Cerveny asks. It is quite clear that the first step to unlocking these possibilities is the mobile terminal, the ‘smartphone’. Users of such mobile devices, like the iPhone and Blackberry, have already become accustomed to the access to information provided by urban-oriented web services that are currently available on most (smart)phones: maps, live transit times, weather information, etc. Even tasks like calling a cab or reserving a table at a restaurant have become like buttons on a remote control for the city. But what about more active uses of service made available in the environment? Think of applications, supported by a new omnipresent network, ‘the cloud’, that enables anyone running iTunes to ‘discover’ the nearest public sound system and stream music to it wirelessly.
VURB Foundation, a framework for policy and design research concerning urban computational systems that was co-founded by Cerveny, is exploring the rapid convergence of new and interactive media and public urban spaces, and investigates how our cultures might come to use networked digital resources to change the way we understand, build, and inhabit cities. VURB operates on the premise that eventually, we can re-shape our cities collectively. The citizen can be an active participant in shaping her environment everywhere he or she goes.
Urbanode-project: first steps in environmental control
Urbanode is a research project initiated by the VURB Foundation in partnership with Digitale Pioniers in Amsterdam. They developed software that enables real-world prototyping of scriptable public space, where environmental controls like lighting, audio, and projection can be controlled via a local javascript server. This local server can then present scripted applications, built around specific tasks and user scenarios, as dynamically discoverable services to citizens in the space, whether via a mobile browser or through gesture and voice commands.
The aim is to understand the implications of ‘digital experience architecture’ as an aspect of urban design, where public space becomes dynamically adaptive to the needs of its occupants and the city weaves together a mesh of these dynamic locations into a platform for citizen-enabling network applications.
Urbanode has started the process of creating public system software by wrapping the controls for lighting control systems, as found in theaters and nightclubs, in a javascript programming framework. A prototype of this system has recently been tested successfully in the Melkweg, one of the premiere venues for live music in Amsterdam, making it possible to change the colors of the lights during a live performance with an Android application. Given the successful pilot, what (other) opportunities does Urbanode provide for controlling the city?
Direct manipulation is perhaps the most straightforward example. A user might come into a dance club or other venue and open their Urbanode browser on their mobile device. The Urbanode browser would query the local server and return a list of applications available in the space. In this scenario, let’s suppose there is only one called “Light Commander”. The user selects this application and the browser retrieves the appropriate web interface, which initially presents a schematic view of the lighting in the space, with each light color-coded to indicate whether it is under the control of the venue operator, another user, or available to be controlled. The user taps on an ‘open’ spotlight and is presented with a control interface with a color wheel, directional controls, sliders for focus and brightness, and light pattern icons. There might also be a timer counting down a short interval until the light reverts to ‘open’ and must be re-acquired.
Environmental control is oriented around locations within the space, rather than specific pieces of controllable hardware. Imagine a restaurant in which each table has network-accessible properties like “mood” or “energy level”. When the diners first sit, they can open the Urbanode browser and scan a symbol on the table with their phone’s camera to login to that space. The application presented is a simple scrolling list of mood choices like “romantic”, “party”, and “family”. Each choice dynamically effects the table-specific lighting brightness, color, and variation over time. These mood choices might also reconfigure the music stream or other audio, and also be displayed to the staff on a separate monitor so they might choose to service tables differently depending on selected mood.
Ambient information applications serve as ways to map data from network sources [web services data, mobile device polling, or sensor data] to attributes of environmental mediation like lighting or audio. Let’s suppose the spotlighting on an obelisk in a public square is programmable using Urbanode. A citizen with permission to control those lights could build an application that displayed realtime sporting information using abstract color patterns and sequences.
In all, the Urbanode-project is an important first step in exploring how data generated by citizens on smartphones, can be stored and made available as a realtime service built around a place or a city as a platform. Parallel to this, some architects, artists and designers are already creating realtime interactive projects at very different scales and in many different guises. Some dominate public squares or transform a building’s facade – others are more intimate. However, all share the ability to draw in users to become active participants and co–creators of content in order to give the audience the opportunity to have a direct impact on the final result.
Emotional landscapes
An example of responsive architecture is NOX’ D-tower in the Dutch city of Doetinchem, which was realized as early as 2003. D-tower is an art installation, commissioned by the city of Doetinchem in the Netherlands, which maps the emotions of the local residents. Every night, the tower in the centre of town lights up in one out of four colors, directly showing the outcome of a daily online survey among 350 people who have to answer questions regarding their mental well being. If most people were ‘happy’ on day 1, the tower would turn blue. If the majority were in ‘love’ on day 2, the tower would glow up red, and so on.
Interactive tools not only enable the expression of individual and collective ideas and emotions through responsive environments and interactive architecture, they can also facilitate forms of community activism and physical change. The web tool SeeClickFix, a mobile application that allows users to report and track non-emergency issues in their neighborhood online via their mobile device, is based on the assumption that an aware, engaged and active public that uses technology can get its city government to efficiently resolve problems. It seeks to use the power of the Internet to bring together all parties involved in city use and improvement and to make neighborhoods better places to live and work.
According to SeeClickFix, “citizens who take the time to report even minor issues and see them fixed are likely to get more engaged in their local communities.” If so, this could trigger a self-reinforcing loop, improving living standards and strengthening social ties in neighborhoods. Their mobile application enables citizens to report issues in real time and in real space; neighborhood groups to monitor and follow issues in their streets, while the police monitors crime issues being reported. But the service also helps city leaders detect patterns that might otherwise have escaped notice. Citizens then vote on neighborhood issues, or promote more efficient community governance by instantly forwarding them to a person who might be able to help, thus giving them direct control. Media use SeeClickFix to build upon citizen-driven news content and attract readership.
Mobile games take the idea of public participation and appropriation to the next level. Shadow Cities is a location based Massively multiplayer online role-playing game (MMORPG) for the iPhone that was recently released in Helsinki. Familiar streets and neighborhoods are part of the game world that is visible to you through your iPhone. It tracks your location via OpenStreetMap and creates a site-specific game world. Because your location in the game reflects your location in real world, your city becomes a game. When you move in the real world you also move in the game. Users can check in to locations as part of the gameplay and interact with players in the same area. Shadow Cities is a virtual world interwoven with the physical world. The game allows players to see what’s happening in the city by jumping to the Cloudview, enabling you to see the activity in different neighborhoods. In the future we will all be able to sit next to God in the gamified city.
Pattern recognition and open source cities
Over the past few years, the emergence of virtual networks and (online) tools for communication has generated an unparalleled amount of digital data. Handheld devices, location based (social) media, the Global Positing System (GPS) and a wide range of RFID-tags are constantly producing a rich stream of data revealing various aspects of urban life. Cities are now completely covered by systems and networks driven by digital data in realtime. And all users of mobile media become data flows, simply by moving around while sharing their whereabouts.
Consistent research and practical experiments by such eminent organizations as Senseable City Lab of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) have employed location based data to better understand how people make use of their cities and how their movements and behavior changes in realtime. Today, it is becoming increasingly relevant to explore ways in which such data streams can become tools for people navigating the city and taking decisions.
Now it is possible to gain important insights in the concentration, duration, frequency and other important indicators of human activities in cities, by collecting location data that mobile devices generate throughout the day. In a way it enables us to see our cities from above, as if we were looking out from an airplane or holding a detailed map, with the additional advantage of seeing the city at once at day-and nighttime and on weekdays and during the weekend.
The digital data reveals digital traces and patterns of human activity in urban environments. Environmental sensors measure characteristics such as air quality, temperature or noise levels; telecommunication networks show connectivity and the location of users; transportation networks digitally trace the flow of people and vehicles as well as products in the city, just to name a few.
The data enables us to detect public gatherings and traffic jams, estimate which neighborhoods are the most crowded, reconstruct commuter-traveling patterns during the course of the day, offering opportunities for all sorts of new services for the benefit of the public, from emergency planning to traffic control, from the efficient allocation of utilities to assessing the impact of new city infrastructures.
For urban planners, designers, property developers, politicians and others, these aggregated digital traces are important sources of information that captures the pulse of the city in an incredible degree of temporal and spatial detail.
Recently Cisco, the world's largest maker of networking equipment, and Living PlanIT, a startup focused on developing large-scale sustainable technologies for construction projects and cities, announced plans to develop a ‘greenfield’ site in northern Portugal as one of Europe's first "smart cities", embedding networking technology in its buildings and infrastructures. They will integrate IT into the fabric of the city, installing hundreds of thousands of sensors that allow an urban operating system to create intelligent buildings that are constantly optimized to enhance comfort, productivity and environmental sustainability. The project is scheduled to begin in 2011.
Of course, such projects and collaborations are not new. Until recently, the information technology sector, architects and the construction and real estate industries seemed to live in parallel worlds. Most previous attempts by information designers and media developers to cross the divide failed over concerns about high costs of new technologies and fears that they were promoting a real life version of Sim City, giving consumers too much power and means for assuming direct control.
However, almost all the technologies they are planning to deploy in PlanIT Valley are available to use at rapidly decreasing costs. You do not need to invent anything new to develop this city: you just have to integrate the right technologies in the right place. Buildings that automatically adjust the indoor temperature because of realtime analytics and dynamic weather forecasts are now viable.
According to Roope Mokka, social scientist and co-founder of think tank Demos Helsinki, the idea of self-built and self-learning cities offers a lot of opportunities for urban development. He suggests that we open it up in the same way we have radically democratized the creation of online encyclopedias and social media, allowing anyone to contribute. Social networking sites already connect people and cluster interests. When these types of virtual systems are used as the mould our physical surroundings and local governance, cities become truly inclusive.
In 2008 Demos Helsinki developed the concept of City 2.0 – an urban ecosystem of social innovation, governance and social risk funding. In the City 2.0 the key element is how citizens re-engage with, and manage, the city. In their vision of a self-built city you could open a daycare centre the same way you write a new entry on Wikipedia. This is made possible by a system of ‘citizen-wikis’ or posting boards. If you think your area needs something, lets say a certain shop, zebra crossing or green space, you could post your needs on a citizen-wiki and be connected with like-minded people to make it happen. This “needs-mapping” system would help shape areas more dynamically than simple markets.
From the citizen-wikis the main demands and needs would be collated and these would then become the key policy initiatives or “commons” for the city. Mokka even suggests that, although cities are slower to build, in 2050 we will have self-built cities or “wikicities”. He reminds us that only a few years ago no-one would have believed that millions of ordinary people (non-professionals) would work together on a an online encyclopedia like Wikipedia. Now we can even question, considering the impact of Wikileaks, how much longer governments can control our cities without publicly sharing the available urban statistics and raw data?
Over the past year, New York City’s Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) has opened up, making large quantities of hard data available to outside developers who have turned the data into useful software applications for local travelers. An example is ITrans.com, featuring maps, easy-to-read schedules and suggested routes between stations for the subway, as well as for systems in other cities. TheNextTrain.com provides easy-to-use train schedules for a handful of cities (though not yet for the New York subway.) CleverCommute.com helps communicating realtime delays to each other via e-mail or text message. As the city shares more data and uses more open source software new businesses that create services out of this data and that support this software will spring up.
Who’s controlling the coded city?
According to Ben Cerveny “the internet, and the open source software that powers much of it, has remained remarkably adaptable to the ideals of democratic and egalitarian societies.” But as cities more and more become dynamic systems that provide services and transform environments, we should carefully consider the ethics and politics of these new, digital infrastructures.
The smart city – which operates in the digital and physical realms at the same time – also poses difficult questions about privacy, participation, and design, among many others. These questions must be addressed as we move toward achieving an augmented, fine-grained understanding of how the city functions – socially, economically and yes, even psychologically.
We are now able to code cities like software – an urban operating system in which buildings, sensors, and traffic apps alike are connected through the cloud. This data-driven approach to urban life makes sense, because cities are in many respects problems of information management. But how will all these new data and interactive tools affect the way we experience and manage cities? Can a city become a game? Who will own and control all the content generated by smart cities – governments, the community or private corporations? And how can the underprivileged and disconnected also benefit from all of this?
The 2010 report “The Future of Cities, Information and Inclusion” written by the social sector office of the global management consultancy McKinsey & Co., provides some answers. It describes several case studies, from mobile electronic systems integration in Istanbul that speed police response to electronic handsets used by New York City’s Department of Homeless Services. It seams that just about everyone benefits because the benefits themselves are so broad: urban informatics can provide faster and cheaper services and improve coordination between planners and service delivery through data sharing, centralized analysis and the reduction of redundancy and transaction costs. Furthermore, the information itself is not just more abundant but is also of higher quality.
So everybody benefits? Not quite yet, because there are still many barriers to be overcome. Technology developers lack real knowledge of cities’ needs and dynamics; government agencies avoid taking risks and often lack the means and expertise to push innovation; and many people are simply hesitant to adopt new technologies. First of all there are (other) resource constraints: funding, talent, infrastructure and access. Secondly there is the access issue, which is not just about affordable devices and mobile applications, but also about ‘digital illiteracy’. As technological innovation keep accelerating and urban informatics becomes central to the functioning of government, trade and society at large the isolation of certain cities and individuals might increase. Thirdly, there is still no solid legal framework for the way governments or companies collect and use data, causing all kinds of discussions revolving around privacy, openness, transparency and inclusiveness. And last but not least, there is the widespread, and deeply rooted, belief among stubborn architects and urban planners that the process of urban development can never be left to computer algorithms, let alone to ‘stupid’ civilians who just happen to live in a ‘smart’ city.